Though she had extraordinary success in the 2024 Paris Olympics, Chiles faced with an obstacle after her floor routine. Initially, she came in fourth place for her routine, but her coach appealed a deduction putting her in third place and getting her a bronze medal.
With that happening Romanian gymnast Ana Barbosu moved down to fourth place. This left the Romanian Gymnastics Federation questioning the validity of the appeal. It was then released that the appeal was submitted four seconds after the one minute window given. This seemingly small mistake caused Chiles to be stripped of her medal. The United States team claims they have proof that they submitted the appeal twice under the one minute window, but they have not been allowed to present it. Some believe that taking the medal was extreme and unfair, but others think it was the right thing to do.
“Rules are rules….If you change the rules for one person, It’s going to get brought up in a different situation and then you’ll have to change the rules again,” said Dean of Students, Mr. James Rydborn.
“Of course it wasn’t fair….The United States team has proof that the appeal was submitted twice within the one minute window,” added English teacher Dr. Rafael Montes
“Yes and no….They should’ve shared the medal since it was a mistake,” concluded Coach Anthony Vuono.
What do you think? Let the Royal Courier know by answering the attached poll.
